A new open-access book by Professor Ben Crewe aims to excavate the ‘social and emotional texture’ of life in close supervision centres - the most restrictive and controlled units in the England and Wales prison system.
‘Deep Confinement: Everyday Imprisonment and Extremity in the Close Supervision Centres’ documents Crewe’s unprecedented access to the centres over two years, including interviews, some lasting two or three hours, with 40 of the men held within them.
Close Supervision Centres were established in 1998 to hold prisoners considered too violent and disruptive to be held in standard prisons. The system comprises five individual units and a number of ‘designated cells’ – specialised cells within segregation units of high security prisons. As a whole, at the time of Crewe’s research, they held over 50 of the most dangerous men in the prison system and operate under acutely controlled conditions.
“These are very extreme environments, but holding very extreme individuals,” says Crewe, Professor of Penology and Criminal Justice, and the Deputy Director of the Prisons Research Centre at the Institute. “These are mainly men that have killed other prisoners, committed serious assaults on staff, or taken staff hostage. The point of this system is really to allow the mainstream prison system to keep running by removing them from it.”
Having trained as a sociologist, Crewe has spent over 20 years researching almost all aspects of prison life, most recently exploring the experiences of men and women serving long life sentences. But the Close Supervision Centres offered an opportunity to dig into the experiences of those held at the very extremes of the system. The conditions in these centres are sometimes likened to solitary confinement, with many prisoners in the system spending considerable time in sole-occupancy cells and given little to no opportunity to interact with other inmates.
“I wanted to shine a light on a part of the system that is very rarely seen,” says Crewe. “There's a lot of research about the psychological impact on individuals of very secure and restrictive conditions, but my research wasn't coming at it from a psychological perspective. I was more interested in the question of what life is like in these units. What is it like to be held in places that are right at the edge of what the state can do to anyone?
“In this country, we don't have capital punishment, so in some senses, the most severe thing that we do to people – other than giving them incredibly long sentences – is holding them in conditions that are as different from that of a free citizen as you can imagine.”
I wanted to shine a light on a part of the system that is very rarely seen. What is it like to be held right at the edge of what the state can do?
Between January 2017 and August 2018, Crewe visited each of the centres and almost all of the designated cells, observing conditions and everyday dynamics, speaking with staff and conducting a series of detailed interviews with prisoners. His book documents the subjective experiences of deep incarceration, and explores staff-prisoner dynamics, psychological power, and the often tense relations between prisoners themselves.
“There were men who described being in these units as a bit like being buried: subterranean and impossible to see a way out,” says Crewe. “People described in very powerful ways the very acute boredom and distress caused by being locked up in a cell for many, many hours of the day, combined with the fact that it really is Groundhog Day for many of these men.”
There was some variation to the conditions in which prisoners were held: in two of the units, men were never allowed to engage in person with their peers, whereas in others, prisoners were able to mix in small, closely supervised groups, though often they chose not to. Access to education or work opportunities was generally limited, although some units had provision for art.
“The cells are not in themselves any worse than most prison cells,” says Crewe. “And you do get a cell to yourself, which tends not to be the case in many prisons. But there's something very bleak about the length of time that people spend in these conditions. Once you're in the CSC system, it takes quite a lot of time to get out because you have to prove that your risk is reduced sufficiently that you can be safely held in ‘normal’ high security conditions.”
The bleakness of the experiences described coupled with the extreme orientation to violence that some of the prisoners were happy to detail made the research some of the most challenging of Crewe’s career.
“I had conducted research with people who had committed very serious offences, but this felt quite different,” says Crewe. “These are easy places to research in some ways – as a researcher, they felt to me much safer than normal prison wings do, because there's so much control built into the environment and so much caution. But some of the men I interviewed were right at the edges of what you might encounter when you have a face-to-face discussion with another human: quite disturbed and quite happy to talk about their propensity for violence. That is really rare in my experience.
“People who don't do prison research maybe imagine that lots of people talk with real delight about the violence that they've committed, but that is very rarely the case. With the study of lifers [conducted with Susie Hulley and Serena Wright], generally people were really ashamed of what they'd done or were capable of reflecting on the moral implications of being involved in someone else's death. And that was true of many of the men in the CSC system, but a handful were, at least superficially, quite proud of their violent histories.
“And what I didn't want to do in the book was shy away from that. Occasionally, I think prison research isn't as upfront as it could be about the relevance of people’s offences. It’s not always relevant, but in this project it was, because that's why they're in these units. And hearing people talk about things that they had done or things that had happened to them was pretty heavy going.”
My aim, as it often is when I do research, is not to fall into the trap of thinking there are simple solutions here.
A common thread throughout his conversations was the prevalence of severe mental health issues among the prisoners. The centres generally have more provision for prisoner mental health support than the mainstream prison system, but some of the men interviewed felt this was still not enough.
“I hadn't expected at the start of the study that that would be such a key issue, but people talked about it all the time,” explains Crewe. “Most men within the CSC system either had quite serious mental health problems or quite severe personality disorders. Only a handful said they didn't and most had multiple diagnoses. So again, these were very complex men: complex in terms of their personal psychology and almost all with very difficult backgrounds and histories.”
Crewe is careful to emphasise the complexity of this situation – while he believes that many of these men should be held in secure psychiatric hospitals, this is not always as viable a solution as it may seem.
“I have been to secure hospitals, and they do have a more therapeutic ethos,” he says. “But if you're very violent in a secure hospital, you're held in isolation for a long period and you might be given heavy drugs against your will, which can't be done in a prison.
“So this was a very complex dynamic and I think there was almost complete consensus among staff and the managers running these units that they desperately needed more resource to support people with their mental health problems and personality disorder issues.”
The lack of simple solutions is a message Crewe returns to throughout the book.
“Part of what the book is trying to say is there are some problems of imprisonment that are fairly intractable. This question of what does society do with men who are very hard to control, or who seem intent on very serious violence? My aim, as it often is when I do research, is not to fall into the trap of thinking there are simple solutions here. There is a movement in many countries away from using very restrictive and solitary confinement. And I'm very pleased about that.
“But I'm trying to describe institutions and individuals on the edge. One question that I asked everyone was whether they felt it was fair that they were in the CSC system. And some of them were almost shocked that I was asking. Their response was ‘of course it's fair - it would be mad for the system not to keep me in very secure conditions because I'm dangerous’. This wasn't always macho boasting. It was sometimes people who just understood themselves and recognised they were very easily triggered into violence.”
Which brings us back to the three conceptual threads running through the book that Crewe calls extremity, tragedy, and the idea of the CSC as a crucible: a place in which humans are subjected to exceptional heat and pressure.
“There's a depth and intensity to the nature of people's experiences here and the individuals themselves. And I want to describe that and make that visible.”
Read the book
‘Deep Confinement: Everyday Imprisonment and Extremity in the Close Supervision Centres’ is published by Palgrave Macmillan and is available to read with open access.